Book Review of We Were Liars

By Robert Drinkwater

We Were Liars is a young adult novel by E. Lockhart that follows an unreliable narrator as she returns to her family’s island two years after a horrific accident. We don’t know what happened to her, but she got a head injury from night, one that resulted in her not remembering most of what happened during that summer.

Cadence Sinclair comes from a wealthy family where they spend every summer on an island off of the coast of Cape Cod. She and her cousins call themselves The Liars. They are all around the same age and once they are on that island, they are inseparable. As a Cape Cod resident I was drawn to this book because of its location, but it was the mystery part that really made me want to read it. Throughout the novel we see Cady try to remember what happened on that island. This accident happened when she was fifteen and two years later she decides to go back to that island with her mom. She wants to remember what happened to her and she believes that going to back to the island will help her recollect her memories.

This book was a fairly quick read. The suspense is what kept me turning the pages. Towards the beginning of the book, I initially thought that the big mystery would be that someone tried to murder her, but it became apparent that there was much more to it. As the story progresses we get little tidbits of her memory, all of which connect to that night.

I thought that it was confusing at times because it would often jump between summer fifteen and seventeen. I do enjoy reading nonlinear timelines, but I would often mistake the past timeline with the present and certain plot points were mixed up. I also thought that the narrator was kind of boring. Every time Gat was mentioned, she would say My Gat, which was kind of irritating. The characters in this novel such as Gat, Mirren, and Johnny were interesting. There wasn’t a whole lot of time in this book to flesh out these characters more due to its short length. Even though they weren’t in it as much, the other characters in that family were interesting as well.

I thought that the author did a good job a portraying a dysfunctional family. The patriarch of the family, Granddad, constantly has his family members competing for his approval in hope of getting his inheritance. The moms of The Liars would try to get their kids to win granddad’s favor. However, I felt like many of the characters were underdeveloped and they lacked three dimensional personalities at times.

Overall, E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars explores a complicated family dynamic and centers around a girl trying to recover her memory from a tragic accident. I thought that the stories pacing was good, and it had a good twist at the end. Something that makes sense if you reread certain parts of the story. Cady trying to put the recollect her fragmented memories of summer fifteen made this a compelling novel full of mystery and suspense with a poignant twist that you won’t forget.

Land Acknowledgements for New Commons Project

By Robert Drinkwater

During this semester every New Commons event begins with a land acknowledgement. The first one was given when the poet Cheryl Savageau came to UMF to read some of her poems. This land acknowledgement was read by UMF’s new president Edward Serna. The land acknowledgment recognizes that this land once belonged to the Indigenous people and that we are on Wabanaki land. The idea of starting off every event with a land acknowledgment came from Kristen Case’s New Commons class.

“I first experienced a land acknowledgement a couple of years ago at a Canadian university,” said Case. “It didn’t really occur to me to do that at UMF until I saw a Facebook post by Nicole Kellett about the practice. I followed up the links about the practices of land acknowledgements. I saw a video of a bunch of Native people saying how meaningful these land acknowledgements are to them.”

Case did some research on land acknowledgements with her colleague, Steve Grandchamp. She said that there are critics of these practices, even by those who are advocates for Native people. “I felt like it was important to find out why and if you are going to do a land acknowledgement, what is important to include in it and what are the best ways to do it.” said Case. This was when Case realized that it would be best to practice this exercise for one of her classes with her students. “We did research about the local area,” said Case, “and the different tribal nations in Maine and to come up with a language that we wanted to use together, so that it was more of a community statement. It felt appropriate for the New Commons Project.”

Case and her students were able to discuss what they had come up with for the land acknowledgement with Lisa Brooks, a scholar of Indigenous studies, who was a keynote speaker for the New Commons event “The Canoe.” Case was able to get input from both Brooks and colleague Sabine Klein who does research on Native American history.

Case had her class work together to figure out what works and what doesn’t, “We had them work in groups for people to find out that information,” said Case. “They had to write a draft for what they would say for a land acknowledgement.” Her class had four different versions of land acknowledgements. Case notes, “We picked out elements we liked from each one and combined them into one final one.”

Land acknowledgements have been read at every New Commons event this semester, and Case said that she wants it to be an ongoing thing, “We wanted to commit to the idea of making an acknowledgement sort of something that we don’t just do once for a Native American speaker, but for something that’s part of our ongoing way of doing things.” She states how it should be something that is a part of everyday life that reminds people of whose land we’re on, “Not just on Indigenous People’s Day,” said Case, “but on every occasion.”

Zion Hodgkin, one of Kristen Case’s students in her New Commons Project class has helped her come up with the land acknowledgement. Zion talks about how in the class the students learned about different cultures throughout time. “We were on a section where we were reading a poetry book by a Native American woman writer,” said Hodgkin. “We decided that because it was her event that it would be a good time to start doing this land acknowledgement.” Hodgkin states that the land acknowledgement is meant to recognize that the land belonged to somebody before us and that we honor that.

The New Commons class worked together to figure out what ideas worked for a land acknowledgement such as researching tribes that lived on this land to make it more relevant to the UMF community. “We looked online at previous examples of land acknowledgements,” said Hodgkin. “We sort of mixed everything together, and made it applicable to us, and made sure that it flowed well.”

“Even though we started it during an event with a Native American writer,” said Hodgkin. “We didn’t want it to be pandering.” Hodgkin believes it is important that a land acknowledgement is read before every New Commons event from here on out, “We wanted it to be something that continued, that even when I’m out of school, or that when the professors are no longer teaching about Native American Studies or at least in the way that they did, that it [the land acknowledgment] will be something that continues throughout the years.”