Barthes’ “Toys” Applied to Modern American Advertising

By: Annie Moloney

In his essay “Toys,” Roland Barthes describes how French toys are “essentially a microcosm of the adult world.” He says “they are all reduced copies of human objects, as if in the eyes of the public the child was, all told, nothing but a smaller man […]” In the essay he goes on to explain the way French toys almost exclusively reflect adult society and do not offer children the opportunity to invent the world in which they play, only to use a world already created for them. He attributes this idea to “the fact that the adult Frenchman sees the child as another self.” Because toy making is left to the adult members of society, Barthes is making the point that they are inherently infused with adult issues.

In many respects, this idea applies to the modern toy market we see in American society today. Many of the toys marketed for American children are based on the concepts of a smaller, more simplified adult world. They are geared toward the child pretending to me “like mommy” or “like daddy” while completing tasks that adults typically don’t do for enjoyment, or view with a considerable measure of responsibility. One such example is a line of baby dolls sold by Fisher Price called “Little Mommy.” In this advertisement for a particular doll known as “the Little Mommy Very Real Baby” a girl is shown caring for the dolls basic needs. The type of play the toy suggests is to simulate the world of a real mother, caring for a child’s wounds, feeding the baby, and putting her to sleep. The name alone is an obvious indication of what is being pushed here. It is the concept that the child’s idea of play should be pretending to have adult responsibilities, and the type of toy the market provides is celebrated as being “very real.” Watching the advertisement through this lens is almost surreal. The attempt to force the adult role of motherhood on a young girl in such an overt manner has the capability to be extremely off-putting if one takes a moment to ponder what is strange concept it is. However, it is a common practice, and most consumers are so inundated with products like this, that there seems nothing odd about it. What other reason would an adult think to create such a toy for a little girl if not for Barthes suggestion that it is in an effort to “condition her for the future roll as mother.”

The point about the meaning behind French toys that Barthes is getting at in his essay is very true of the American toy industry. The fact that the toys are created by adults reduces the child to the user of whatever is provided for them, and often what is provided is geared toward adult interest, rather than the child’s. The Little Mommy doll is just one example.

In addition to toys that simulate adult life, the American toy market is also replete with toys that are geared toward some type of fantasy world. While this might not be as obvious an attempt at recreating the adult world, it subtly reflects what Barthes suggests about adults seeing children as “another self.” The child is not responsible for creating the toy, the adult is, and what might seem appealing to an adult is the type of game that allows one to escape reality. These type of toys often come from movie franchise or books such as Star Wars and Harry Potter, that are actually geared toward an older audience, but have merchandise that is targeted at younger children.

Barthes’ assertion that, “French toys are usually based on imitation” and that, “they are meant to produce children who are users, not creators” is something that can be traced to the American toy market as well. The type of toys found on the shelves of Toys R Us and Walmart are the type geared toward creating consumers not creators. In today’s capitalist market, most messages from the media and advertising world prompt this sort of consumer behavior. From a young age, children are taught what type of toys they are supposed to play with, and those toys are supposed to prepare them to grow up and conform to certain societal standards. Most of the toys available today encourage conformity into adulthood, rather than embracing the creativity of childhood.


Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: